Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Our Gray Wednesday

New York Moments:

Walking all over Canal Street and Chinatown looking for a miniature tea set for a gift only to be told by the one vendor who has them that they'll be in on Black Friday.

Traveling from 236th to 14th Street only to find one out of 3 shops open simply because the other two randomly decided to be closed early on the one day we'd been planning on going shopping on for over a week. (When will we ever learn we need to call first regardless?)

Chatting with 2 life-long Upper West Side residents at Community Food and Juice Bar and being given the advice that one thing we should do before leaving NYC is go to Governor's Island--yet they've never been.

Watching Santa with short brown hair standing along a dark row of brownstones light up while Rudolf held her head and blocked the wind leaning over a shopping cart.

Friday, October 23, 2009

Real New Yorkers

I have been amused, lately, by the true New Yorkers who have crossed our path. They are quick, to-the-point, brusque, engaging, sharp, well meaning, and have no time for frivolous pleasantries. For instance, after parking the car on the Mon./Thurs. side of the street, I couldn't help but pick up a few red and orange leaves. Blissfully enjoying a kids-free moment with the crisp morning air, and golden rays of sunshine just begging to be basked in, I encountered a white-haired, well-dressed woman. I smiled with a smirk of being caught in a childish pursuit, and bestowed her with "Good Morning" anyway. She had kindness in her eyes, but instead of repeating the salutation she replied, "Dogs pee there." I managed out "Oh, OK" and looked down at the beautiful carpet of leaves.

"Doesn't matter does it?" she grinned and kept on walking. I like to think she remembered a day when she didn't care about being so proper. Either that or her knees prevented her from picking some up too, because they are so darn pretty right now. And she was too, in her own way.

People from the South or the Midwest often write off New Yorkers as being rude--I did too. But now that I've had a chance to see them living just like people do everywhere, I am starting to understand them. And, I honked my horn without malice *gasp* for the first time today. Everyone's in a hurry here--it's just a polite way to say, "you can go now", or "hold it", or "since you're not moving, watch out, because I am!" Don't get me wrong, there are those who will start honking their horns to get the line moving before you even have a green light, but mostly horns are an extension of the New Yorker's vocabulary. Don't take offense, you're the only one who's going to get fed up.

Listening to the Bronx accent is fabulous. Listening to the Italian Bronx accent is even better. Listening to the Jewish Bronx accent is entertaining. Listening to people try and imitate it is embarrassing. Just come and hear it for yourself. There's nothing like catching a grocery store conversation with the wife standing next to an enormous row of gefilte fish, and nasally saying, "What are you talking about? No, I told you to get the matza. Go back, it's right over there."

With the temperatures lowering, I've been wearing hats more often. Unlike most places, I am not in the minority since the Jewish population in Riverdale seems to be very conservative. Most Jewish mothers wear some kind of head covering, and on the Sabbath they are all dressed to the hilt. I don't know if I look enough like a local to be asked if I know where the Kosher pizza place is, but I do. Yes, I overheard a man in a yamaka ask someone that once.

While New York City is a very diverse place, a common thread I see running through all the "real" New Yorkers is pride--of a good kind. They are proud to be making it here, proud to know the histories of the the neighborhoods, proud to tell the transients how to best manuver the bus and subway routes, and proud enough to not care who knows it. They'll hand you back whatever you dropped in the street, give you directions, coo at your baby, argue about which route is better, ignore you if you're hoping to mind your own business, carry your stroller up the subway steps, give a dollar if they don't have the change, and try to enlighten you as to where dogs do business.

Friday, October 2, 2009

Where do they all come from?

When people wonder what makes New York so intriguing, besides the usual glamor of Times Square, Grand Central Terminal and the like, I know they have not taken a ride on the subway. This past week Amy and Matthew Cox came for a visit, and we did justice to the city by showing them the ins and outs of neighborhoods, tourist sites and, of course, subways. During our great time we came across all kinds of interesting people and subsequently stories to take back home.

While I wish I could find time to tell about all our adventures, such as riding the Staten Island Ferry twice in one day to find a lost blankie, listening to awesome Irish/Celtic music in a little hidden pub, and advantageously taking a wrong route through Central Park, I'd like to expound about the common crazies found above and underground. More than once they caused Amy and I to exchange a stifled smile, giving us conversation afterward.

The first woman we noticed entered the subway with a toy Barbeque and wearing clothes meant for a much smaller size. She proceeded to try and sit on the plastic toy which kept sliding out from underneath her. Eventually frustrated by her attempts she stood up, and promptly lost her seat to another passenger. When she looked around for another, Amy scooted over and I nodded at the open seat next to us. The woman, whose utterances were unintelligible until then, spoke with a voice as smooth as a jazz singer's and said, "Thank you baby, I'll remember you!" She winked and blew a kiss, and I was afraid I'd regret the kindness. But after she got off and on again at the following two stops, she finally settled at leaving us when we arrived at the third.

For some reason I have retained a very clear mental picture of her. She had a half-grown afro, was squeezed into a dirty yellow halter top, splitting on the side seams, belly hanging out and over her Hawaiian print mini-skirt wearing fuzzy brown slippers. I couldn't tell if she was pregnant, but please say a prayer for her. What if she could have been this century's Billie Holiday had life turned out differnt for her?

Another day I sat next to an Eleanor Rigby who asked me question after question of how I went about taking care of my children. She asked how I did diapering, what kind of cribs were safe or acceptable, where I bought clothes, etc. until I began to wonder what her motives were. A few stops before she got off she revealed that she was expecting triplets. Surely she meant her daughter or granddaughter, as she appeared well beyond the child bearing age, but no.

She pointed to where the face of one was, the shoulder of the 2nd and said the 3rd was transverse below. As she went on about how the technicians were rude to her she also explained that she wasn't sure when each one was conceived, and mumbled something about maybe there were 5. Had she been younger she would have nearly convinced me except for that last comment. I could tell she was pleased to have a listening ear, but my countenance must have betrayed my belief of her credibility towards the end because as she left she said to me, "My psychologist says I need to let it all go, but it's true, it's all true. I wouldn't tell you about it if it wasn't. Why would I go on about it if it wasn't true!"

Within the span of the same week I was also acknowledged in our local Target by a dazed college-age man who simply said, "I like your nails." Taken aback by the compliment, because I do not have nice nails, I replied, "What?" He repeated his phrase and nodded to my toenails which were painted, though not professionally. "Oh, thanks" I replied and shook his extended hand as I tried to ascertain if he was all there, or if that was supposed to be a pick-up line.

I run into these kinds of people all the time, and yet I am still surprised by the odd little comments. I guess I shouldn't be, this is New York, and how many of us have said crazy things now and then. But I think this city has it's fair share of common crazies. What I wonder mostly though, is where are their families? Do they have any? What about friends? What role has the church played, if at all, in their lives? Where would any of us be if it were not for those that love us.

"All the lonely people..."

Monday, September 7, 2009

Another New Apartment

We made it to the Bronx. New apartment, 1000 square feet, 2 bedrooms, brand new Kitchen Aid appliances, etc. Took the true convection oven for a test run last night. First recipe--coconut macaroons--sweet! Who knew I could fall in love with an oven.

Later today, after a song and dance required before the first use of the washer and dryer, I plan to see if my clothes can obtain nirvana as well. Doubtful, but at least I was amused by the obviously over tired employee who had the crappy job of writing the user manual. "Measure out the correct amount of detergent relieves the strain on to be kind to the environment and to help ensur optimum washing results."

And can anyone explain this: "If you are using too little detergent, calcification of heather may occur." What the heck is heather, if not the pretty little fragrant flower, doing in my washer? Also, did you know that "items of clothing that have been pre-treated with solvent-based cleaning agents, e.g. stain remover or dry cleaning chemical, could represent a potential explosion hazard in the contained area of the washing machine."? So pray for me as I attempt to use my non-straining to be kind to the environment, heather calciferous, internal exploding, clothes cleaning? washing machine.

Friday, August 14, 2009

Fleeting Moments

I have been too tired and worn out this summer to write much, so here is a journal entry from May that I ran across. I still smile in remembering Cyan so tiny.

There are moments in life so fleeting that savoring them in the now is almost impossible. Times of pure joy that transcend all selfish desires of fulfillment. The glimpse leaves you wanting more, but it would cease to be as special if it was more than the moment in which you found it.

I had one of those moments while holding my newborn son. Trying to recapture the memory is impossible, but describing the emotions and the facts can help re-create a portion of it.

As I trace his perfect little ear while he nurses, and marvel at the intricacy of the folds, I am overwhelmed with the thought that this tiny ear on this little (yet so big!) human was in me three weeks ago. Three weeks ago I didn't know him--not really. I was tired of being pregnant, and excited about the future with a new baby, but I was unable to comprehend the beauty of a new life from within. His tiny fingers clasp mine and I realize how small the bones of his pinkie finger are. His whole little finger is half the size of mine, and he has long fingers! I watch his facial expressions, and see glimpses of what emotions he will throw my way later on.

How could I not know him when I carried him for 9 months? Why does it make such a difference to see his face, and delight in his smell, and find pride in the way he looks intently at my face? It has only been three weeks, and yet, I feel like he has been here all along, without me knowing. Perhaps his soul was knit with mine in some way, and now that our bodies are separate I must get to know him separately. Each sigh and "smile" I see are noted. I find myself staying up later than I should just to hold him in my arms, gazing at his sleeping face, not understanding why I can't just put him down. Even to write this I had to use all my mental power to let him go, and now I'm by his bed listening to his rhythmic breathing, squeaks and sighs. This instinct, this love, this bond is so magnetic it baffles my intellect. How can I desire to stay up late holding my baby when I have the next 18 or so years to spend with him, and what I desperately need right now is sleep? I guess three weeks is still not long enough for separation adjustment--perhaps you never separate completely.

Thursday, July 16, 2009

That Was Random

Ever have one of those days when you can't seem to quit pondering the meaning of life? Mine has been extended into the past couple of weeks. The "what should, could, would" questions. The fast pace of such a slow life. The worry of what will be left for our children, and not really knowing if anything we do will make a difference in the big picture of things. The exasperation of which sofa to buy or whether to buy one at all. The staving off of guilt from looking at the ground, walking on. The frustration at the lack of choices. The minutes wasted on procrastination. The waiting.

I think I need to get out of my head, but right now it's too hot outside.

Sunday, June 14, 2009

Little Boys

Cyan 7 weeks old and smiling.
We have been taking daily excursions to the park or library so it seems like Cyan is always in this car seat. A couple of days ago, on one such trip, I overheard a large nanny yell repeatedly, "Hey Butt! Do you see ____? Butt! Look!" I kept glancing her way wondering why on earth she would be so demeaning to the oblivious little boy while trying to educate him as to his surroundings. Later, when he was sitting near her I heard the woman call him "Buddy" and it dawned on me. She had been projecting, "Bud!", with the southern accent laid on so thick it sounded very different from my end of the park. She was really intentional about what she was trying to teach her charge--I just hope his mother never hears her yell it that way!
I love this outfit on him!
Big brother, Creighton, holding Cyan for the first time. And Creighton being a two-year-old back in NYC. His latest phrase, "I has to do it myself!" I wish he would be that insistent when it comes to using the toilet!
We have been thinking about friends all over while getting to know people here, thus the old pics I was reminiscing through. Strangers in Georgia have been really friendly though. We stopped at a garage sale and ended up having an hour long conversation about the neighborhood and history. At a diner called The Flying Biscuit we chatted with a lady and her two kids and ended up spending the following Saturday morning with them and her husband. They showed us around another neighborhood and took us to the Atlanta Botanical Gardens. Their children are so lucky, they are growing up with three languages; she is from Colombia and her husband is Persian. This Sunday an after church conversation lengthened into a lunch with a couple expecting their first child. How, I wonder, do we find all the home-schoolers everywhere we go? This husband was the oldest of 7 and home-schooled, needless to say, he and Ben had similar experiences to share.

Sunday, June 7, 2009

Atlanta Apartment

We're drinking in the warm weather, enjoying the larger apartment,
and the pool,
and the ability to eat al fresco on our porch,
Align Centerbut missing all our dear friends in other cities, states and countries.

Friday, May 22, 2009

The Good Life Trade

Ben often sends New York Times articles my way when he thinks they may be of some interest to me.Today he sent me one that reminded me of my dad, and the values he taught. The Case for Working With Your Hands by Matthew B. Crawford was well written and struck a chord with my hard work ethic. As a teenager I actually didn't mind de-tasseling corn, delighting at being outside during the early hours of the day. It also allowed me a chance to really think, pray and exercise my ascetic self. Sometimes I wonder if there is a business that could touch on the feeling I had as I put in a full day's work. Crawford, who is having his book, “Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry Into the Value of Work", published this week, ponders this about a motorcycle specialist,
"Fred’s life as an independent tradesman gave me an image that I kept coming back to: someone who really knows what he is doing, losing himself in work that is genuinely useful and has a certain integrity to it. He also seemed to be having a lot of fun."
I'm not comparing de-tasseling corn with Fred's business, but I have always been on the lookout for a kinesetic job that has integrity and qualities that give a sense of satisfaction at the end of the day. My floral business arranging original designs for brides came as close to fulfilling this as anything. Perhaps it was the personal aspect of direct interaction with clients combined with a tactile skill. I identify with Crawford's sense of place because customers became more like friends throughout the process.

"As is the case with many independent mechanics, my business is based entirely on word of mouth. I sometimes barter services with machinists and metal fabricators. This has a very different feel than transactions with money; it situates me in a community. The result is that I really don’t want to mess up anybody’s motorcycle or charge more than a fair price. You often hear people complain about mechanics and other tradespeople whom they take to be dishonest or incompetent. I am sure this is sometimes justified. But it is also true that the mechanic deals with a large element of chance.

I once accidentally dropped a feeler gauge down into the crankcase of a Kawasaki Ninja that was practically brand new, while performing its first scheduled valve adjustment. I escaped a complete tear-down of the motor only through an operation that involved the use of a stethoscope, another pair of trusted hands and the sort of concentration we associate with a bomb squad. When finally I laid my fingers on that feeler gauge, I felt as if I had cheated death. I don’t remember ever feeling so alive as in the hours that followed.

Often as not, however, such crises do not end in redemption. Moments of elation are counterbalanced with failures, and these, too, are vivid, taking place right before your eyes. With stakes that are often high and immediate, the manual trades elicit heedful absorption in work. They are punctuated by moments of pleasure that take place against a darker backdrop: a keen awareness of catastrophe as an always-present possibility. The core experience is one of individual responsibility, supported by face-to-face interactions between tradesman and customer."

It is so true that the feeling of responsibility can be overwhelming when the potential for catastrophe is just around the corner. There is definitely a buzz of excitement when the flowers are picked up for an event, because working with nature, no matter how engineered the cut-flower industry is, you never know what surprises are in store. I was the responsible one playing the role of designer, consultant, salesman and manager, experiencing the social aspects of each position. The one that challenged me the most was that of consultant, because it forced me to act more like a middle manager in the sense that I was maintaining an image of my business to the bride. Crawford compares this role with the independent tradesman:

Contrast the experience of being a middle manager. This is a stock figure of ridicule, but the sociologist Robert Jackall spent years inhabiting the world of corporate managers, conducting interviews, and he poignantly describes the “moral maze” they feel trapped in. Like the mechanic, the manager faces the possibility of disaster at any time. But in his case these disasters feel arbitrary; they are typically a result of corporate restructurings, not of physics. A manager has to make many decisions for which he is accountable. Unlike an entrepreneur with his own business, however, his decisions can be reversed at any time by someone higher up the food chain (and there is always someone higher up the food chain). It’s important for your career that these reversals not look like defeats, and more generally you have to spend a lot of time managing what others think of you. Survival depends on a crucial insight: you can’t back down from an argument that you initially made in straightforward language, with moral conviction, without seeming to lose your integrity. So managers learn the art of provisional thinking and feeling, expressed in corporate doublespeak, and cultivate a lack of commitment to their own actions. Nothing is set in concrete the way it is when you are, for example, pouring concrete.

Luckily I was also the one "higher up the food chain"! I've worked at companies where I did not have the luxury of being able to change my mind about decisions, and was forced to consider personal integrity with company image. I keep wondering if there is any business out there that would be suited to my preferences and convictions other than my own start-up. At times I also think there's no profit in any trade that I could confidently pursue, but Crawford thinks differently.

Ultimately it is enlightened self-interest, then, not a harangue about humility or public-spiritedness, that will compel us to take a fresh look at the trades. The good life comes in a variety of forms. This variety has become difficult to see; our field of aspiration has narrowed into certain channels. But the current perplexity in the economy seems to be softening our gaze. Our peripheral vision is perhaps recovering, allowing us to consider the full range of lives worth choosing. For anyone who feels ill suited by disposition to spend his days sitting in an office, the question of what a good job looks like is now wide open.

Thank goodness!

Now to ponder whether or not the stay-at-home mom has found that peculiar variety of the good life. And by whose definition?

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Life in short

My idea of a break today is taking 5 minutes to actually rub all the lotion in my hands between changing yet another diaper.

Since I have a few more moments before the next one, here's an update on life in short.

We took planes, trains and automobiles to Texas to visit Ben's family. Cyan, at 3 1/2 weeks old, did very well on the trip. My nerves were frazzled by the end of it all, but he did great. Creighton's ears bothered him doubly because he has molars coming in. Poor kid. Bob was able to hold his most recent grandchild, so we were glad to have gone.

Creighton was actually happy to see subway trains at 1:00 am. I guess it meant he felt like he was somewhere familiar. I wasn't as content until my bobbing head found my pillow. Now we are trying to rise at a decent hour to begin the packing process. Our next adventure starts on the 30th. We will see how the boys do with 3 days of driving!

All I keep thinking is that in about 10 days I'll have a dishwasher. And laundry that needs to be done at 12:30 am will not require going downstairs only to find I've run out of credit on my laundry card. Yes, I'm looking forward to Atlanta. I hear there's good gardening to be found there too.

Time for a diaper change.....

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Cyan Louis

What happens when a lighting designer and an artist have a child? They name him after a primary color, of course! It seems fitting that Cyan, which means blue, intersects both the additive and subtractive color theory worlds. He's our true blue boy. Ben, a fan of baseball, also really likes it because "Cy" is the nickname of the famous pitcher, Cy Young.

We settled upon Cyan after playing around with variations of other names and trying to combine them with the middle name of Louis. Louis is the name of Ben's grandfather, a Korean War veteran, and Methodist minister from the South who was kicked out of his church because he thought it would be alright if the black women Bible study met with the white women Bible study. It is also the middle name of Ben's father, brother and nephew--all of which are second born boys like Cyan.

Cyan was born on Sunday, April 19 after only 3 1/2 hours of labor, with 45 minutes of it in the taxi on the way to the hospital. Shortly after he was born my midwife said, "Yeah, she would be a good candidate for a home birth next time." Ben, however, says, "No way! It's such a mess, and I'm not cleaning it up!"

At 8lbs. 5oz. and 21", Cyan was not a small baby, but he weighed 4 oz. less than Creighton. There are many similarities between the two, yet Cyan is already showing he has a personality all his own. On the first day he tried to lift his head, and was fixated upon my face. Now, as he looks intently, he makes many facial expressions and delights us with lots of "smiles". He is very responsive to people who are singing or talking close enough for him to see, and is overall very content. His body structure is finer than Creighton's, but he's a good eater and gained 14oz. by week two. His swirl of strawberry blond hair is "So soft." as Creighton puts it.

Creighton is ambivalent towards his brother most of the time. What he really wants is my attention--all the time. There has been a definite learning curve in going from one to two children, but we're finding a balance. I've found myself really enjoying moments with just Creighton as well as delighting in the sweetness of a newborn without all the fretfulness of being a first-time mother.

I really treasured this past weekend when, thanks to Ben staying with Cy (my hero!), I took Creighton to a kids' carnival, and had a quintessential New York moment with my "big boy". After the street fair, and a healthy meal of chips and a hot dog, we walked through Columbia's campus and found Mister Softee. The ice cream truck didn't have it's bells on, but Creighton was in quiet awe as he requested a "red one". He giggled quietly with a mouth full of cherry dipped ice cream cone as we waited for the bus to take us down Broadway, and I thought it the best $2.50 I've spent in a long time.

I can hardly wait to have two little boys to "mess it up" with sans stroller or infant carrier, but for now I'm marveling at the miracle of another new life. I'm truly grateful for this little blessing and amazed at how the time passes so quickly now that he's here. Thank you to everyone who prayed for us, and helped us through the long 9 months of waiting for Cyan Louis.

Sunday, April 12, 2009

Sleepy Boy



"I curl up tight to have sweet dreams, I am a sleepy boy!"

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Trip to Philadelphia

With the birth of our second child coming soon we decided to take one last quick trip over Ben’s spring break. We took a Bolt bus to Philadelphia, and saw the Liberty Bell, and Independence Hall, as well as the trendy downtown area. We asked the locals about the best place to get a Philly Cheese Steak, and other favorites. A lady with a fluffy, white, Siberian husky named Daisy directed us to Ishkabibble's Eatery where we pulled up an old painted stool to the tiniest of ledges, and dripped cheese onto the wrappers. Famous performers, and singers graced the walls with their autographed portraits in cheap frames. The sound of steak being chopped and regulars grabbing orders “To-Go” filled the narrow space, which was about as wide as I was. Creighton kept asking, “ More MEAT! Please”, and finally, satisfied, happily galloped down the sidewalk to our next local stop.

After inspecting every little staircase or ledge or piece of curb along the way, we arrived at The Foodery. It was recommended as the only place to purchase several Philadelphia breweries’ ales, and what better week to peruse the selection than the week we happened to tour the city—“Beer Week”. I didn’t know cities had beer weeks, but from the looks of McGillen’s, the oldest continuously run pub in Philadelphia, it might as well have been St. Patrick’s Day already.


Our most delightful find was the newly renovated Le Bar Lyonnais, located below Le Bec-Fin, a "gastronomical destination" restaurant. Wild mushroom risotto with succulent duck and cocoa emulsion topped with micro-greens, snails swimming in a hazelnut cream reduction served in an actual silver cup, pommes frites with a range of mustards, imported and local cheeses with grapes…this is just the bar menu. Well, as if these selections were not enough, the chef decided to play in the kitchen. And we were only too glad to sample. A little something with salmon mousse on an Asian spoon, mushroom “cappuccino” served in demitasse cups, thinly toasted triangles with complex dollops of seafood and fresh garden flavors, and a couple more that would require a professional’s description. Having been re-opened only a month, the proprietors decided what

better way to help patrons linger past the happy hour than to tempt them with a showcase of bites worthy of Le Cordon-Bleu. They had us anyway. We supped, and reminisced about Paris, and old friends while being cared for by an attentive staff. After a brief and chilly walk around a few blocks we decided to return for dessert. Actually, Ben had a beer flight while I had a cake "flight". The various sweets were prettier to look at than to eat, but it was still a great experience as we chatted with the bartender from Brooklyn.

Life has been busy, busy ever since, but it was sure nice to take some family time, and a break from our little apartment in NYC. I haven't had many spare moments lately, so if you see a few less posts, don't worry, we're just getting ready for baby, a move to Atlanta for the summer, an internship, and more. Life. Full.

Sunday, March 1, 2009

Remembering March in Minnesota

There were migrating birds singing.
Brave little birds who were going to be snowed on for their foolishness.
March in Minnesota was ever a lion masquerading as a lamb.
We knew better, but their song caused our hearts to hope
that maybe, just maybe
we could plant our tomatoes earlier this year.

Monday, February 2, 2009

Slumdog Millionaire

If you have not seen Slumdog Millionaire you absolutely must go see it. The plot, character development, scenery and acting are all brilliant. The story line was based on the book Q & A by Vikas Swarup in which a young man from the slums becomes a winner on India's version of Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?

Ben and I saw it a couple weekends ago after he returned from his trip to India with Columbia Business School. All through the movie Ben kept saying, "I was at that place!" and "It looks just like that!" He thought it did a fantastic job of capturing the spirit of the people he saw. So if you want a taste of more than the grand Taj Mahal and subsequently named hotel it is worth a peek.

More than that, it offers a glimpse into the way millions of people really live in India. It was almost more than I could take. We walked away with a strong desire to expand our prayers to regularly include the people of India and let the significance of the things we saw sink into our hearts. In fact, all of the students who went with Ben on the 2-week trip came away saying that seeing the Dharavi slums had made the most lasting impact on their future outlook.

National Geographic artistically photographed pieces of the slum, but as Ben said, "The pictures are cleaned up and don't capture the stench of poor conditions and suffocating pollution." In stark contrast to this side of India is the amazing speed at which the economy is taking off, and pulling people out of abject poverty. Ben's group met one such fellow who grew up in the slums and now works for JP Morgan. Interestingly enough he still chooses to live there with his family and was recently mentioned in a fascinating CNN story. Krishna Pujari of Reality Tours and Travel, the company that took Ben and his classmates through, was quoted as saying,
“People have a negative image that it is dangerous, that there is crime and the children are not going to school, but we are showing them a positive side of the slum.”
Ben experienced many faces of India from the hawking of handmade goods in crowded markets to a dinner with a princess at her palace, from the Reserve Bank of India to media conglomerates, from riding elephants to limousines, from tours of the Lotus Temple to the slums of Dharavi. The contrasts are amazing. Slumdog Millionaire, go see it.

Pictures courtesy of Christian Toraldo.

Ben's Reflections on India

When Ben left on the Chazen Institute study tour of India with Columbia Business School he was not sure exactly what to expect. He knew that it was a wonderful opportunity to learn about India's economy and to travel to a place he had never been before, but the impact of what he saw and heard left a lasting impression on him and his fellow travelers. Here are some of his reflections.

Places: India is a land of contrasts. The Taj Mahal is probably the most beautiful man-made structure ever built, Hindu temples are marvels of carved marble, and the gardens surrounding the tomb of Humayan are silent and serene. Yet these beautiful places are surrounded by dilapidated, filthy, and polluted cities that are choked with traffic, dogs, cows, and people.

Company visits inevitably began by charging through these crowded streets since our buses often could not drop us off in front of the office that we were visiting in India. The offices themselves seemed like they had been hastily put together – cubicles were crowded together and there was rarely a conference room large enough to allow all 30 of us to sit down. The exceptions were the government buildings. They were old but larger and were not nearly as crowded.

Our hotels were very nice – as nice as any four-star hotel in the US. They stood in stark contrast to their surrounding, and offered a welcome refuge from the noise and filth outside. They were obviously aimed at Westerners and were very expensive by Indian standards. Most prices were about the same as NYC. Most of these hotels had nice restaurants and nightclubs on the premises. These and the other restaurants and clubs we visited seemed to mostly attract Westerners and westernized Indians.

Food: Indian food was all that I expected it to be: a complex, spicy, and tasty. Interestingly enough, the differences between Indian dishes are fairly subtle. Almost everything is served in a pot with some sort of sauce to be eaten with rice or bread, (naan or roti) and have the same basic spices- I am guessing coriander, cumin, turmeric, chiles. Dishes were always spicy, but varied in sweetness, acidity, and of course the spices added in addition the base spices, etc. It kind of felt like I was eating the same thing for breakfast lunch and dinner. I loved the taste, though, so I didn’t really mind, and just had western items on the menu every once in a while for variety. I mostly ate vegetarian because it seemed to cause fewer stomach problems

Culture/People: Generally speaking, I found people in India to be very hospitable, kind, and deferential. Whenever we visited a business or politician, we were unfailingly served coffee, tea, and cookies or other sweets. Anyone working at a hotel or restaurant or hotel was impeccably polite and would jump to offer whatever service they could. At the same time, I felt that people would tell you whatever you wanted to hear whether it was true or not, and were very indirect. The exception to this rule were the hawkers and beggars that surround all of the tourist areas. They would shove merchandise in your face, tug at your elbows, and swarm you if you did not keep moving. People would take pictures of you at historical sites and then try to guilt you into buying prints from them later. I found this aspect of Indian society incredibly unpleasant.

Also, India gets things done by throwing people at problems. You are literally waited on hand and foot. Repairs at an historical site were being done by an army of workers on bamboo scaffolding with the same tools they probably used hundreds of years ago. My favorite example of this aspect of human labor across the society was something that I observed at a restaurant/fair/historical site/attraction call Choki Danhi in the city of Jaipur. There was small ferris wheel running; it was probably only 20 feet high. It was somewhat dark outside, so I did not really observe how it was operated until I got fairly close. I did a double take when I realized that the wheel was being propelled by a man who was running in the middle of ferris wheel like a hamster in a cage!

The crazy thing about India is that it is literally leapfrogging over several centuries. People living in conditions like the 1600’s in Europe are going to school and becoming computer technicians, and this is happening very, very rapidly. Businesses grow from 60 people and a few million dollars in sales to nationwide brands with billions of dollars in a matter of 5-10 years. India is changing very quickly, and the largest growth opportunities are in these emerging economies. This fact of course brings about a problem; they are ramping up their pollution and consumption even as they ramp up their economy. But how can we tell these countries that they should not undertake the development that will lift their people out of poverty, especially when Western economies developed with the unrestricted use of fossil fuels?

I believe that it is the responsibility of countries which developed without restrictions on their use of fossil fuels to develop and pay for the technologies that will enable emerging economies to develop sustainably. This is only way that we can both save our planet and retain our position of leadership in the world.

Check out the pictures from this article in National Geographic. They sort of capture the feeling of the place, but make it look a little nicer than it is. Maybe it is the fact that the camera makes the spaces look larger than they are, and that you can’t smell a picture. Still, looking at these reminds me of the place and catches in my throat a bit. This is one of the nicer slums. I don’t want to ever forget this. I want our children to be aware of the global poor.

Pictures courtesy of Christian Toraldo.