Sunday, March 1, 2009
Monday, February 2, 2009
Slumdog Millionaire
Ben and I saw it a couple weekends ago after he returned from his trip to India with Columbia Business School. All through the movie Ben kept saying, "I was at that place!" and "It looks just like that!" He thought it did a fantastic job of capturing the spirit of the people he saw. So if you want a taste of more than the grand Taj Mahal and subsequently named hotel it is worth a peek.
More than that, it offers a glimpse into the way millions of people really live in India. It was almost more than I could take. We walked away with a strong desire to expand our prayers to regularly include the people of India and let the significance of the things we saw sink into our hearts. In fact, all of the students who went with Ben on the 2-week trip came away saying that seeing the Dharavi slums had made the most lasting impact on their future outlook.
National Geographic artistically photographed pieces of the slum, but as Ben said, "The pictures are cleaned up and don't capture the stench of poor conditions and suffocating pollution." In stark contrast to this side of India is the amazing speed at which the economy is taking off, and pulling people out of abject poverty. Ben's group met one such fellow who grew up in the slums and now works for JP Morgan. Interestingly enough he still chooses to live there with his family and was recently mentioned in a fascinating CNN story. Krishna Pujari of Reality Tours and Travel, the company that took Ben and his classmates through, was quoted as saying,
“People have a negative image that it is dangerous, that there is crime and the children are not going to school, but we are showing them a positive side of the slum.”Ben experienced many faces of India from
Pictures courtesy of Christian Toraldo.
Ben's Reflections on India
Company visits inevitably began by charging through these crowded streets since our buses often could not drop us off in front of the office that we were visiting in India. The offices themselves seemed like they had been hastily put together – cubicles were crowded together and there was rarely a conference room large enough to allow all 30 of us to sit down. The exceptions were the government buildings. They were old but larger and were not nearly as crowded.
Our hotels were very nice – as nice as any four-star hotel in the US. They stood in stark contrast to their surrounding, and offered a welcome refuge from the noise and filth outside. They were obviously aimed at Westerners and were very expensive by Indian standards. Most prices were about the same as NYC. Most of these hotels had nice restaurants and nightclubs on the premises. These and the other restaurants and clubs we visited seemed to mostly attract Westerners and westernized Indians.
Food: Indian food was all that I expected it to be: a complex, spicy, and tasty. Interestingly enough, the differences between Indian dishes are fairly subtle. Almost everything is served in a pot with some sort of sauce to be eaten with rice or bread, (naan or roti) and have the same basic spices- I am guessing coriander, cumin, turmeric, chiles. Dishes were always spicy, but varied in sweetness, acidity, and of course the spices added in addition the base spices, etc. It kind of felt like I was eating the same thing for breakfast lunch and dinner. I loved the taste, though, so I didn’t really mind, and just had western items on the menu every once in a while for variety. I mostly ate vegetarian because it seemed to cause fewer stomach problems
Culture/People: Generally speaking, I found people in India to be very hospitable, kind, and deferential. Whenever we visited a business or politician, we were unfailingly served coffee, tea, and cookies or other sweets. Anyone working at a hotel or restaurant or hotel was impeccably polite and would jump to offer whatever service they could. At the same time, I felt that people would tell you whatever you wanted to hear whether it was true or not, and were very indirect. The exception to this rule were the hawkers and beggars that surround all of the tourist areas. They would shove merchandise in your face, tug at your elbows, and swarm you if you did not keep moving. People would take pictures of you at historical sites and then try to guilt you into buying prints from them later. I found this aspect of Indian society incredibly unpleasant.
The crazy thing about India is that it is literally leapfrogging over several centuries. People living in conditions like the 1600’s in Europe are going to school and becoming computer technicians, and this is happening very, very rapidly. Businesses grow from 60 people and a few million dollars in sales to nationwide brands with billions of dollars in a matter of 5-10 years. India is changing very quickly, and the largest growth opportunities are in these emerging economies. This fact of course brings about a problem; they are ramping up their pollution and consumption even as they ramp up their economy. But how can we tell these countries that they should not undertake the development that will lift their people out of poverty, especially when Western economies developed with the unrestricted use of fossil fuels?
I believe that it is the responsibility of countries which developed without restrictions on their use of fossil fuels to develop and pay for the technologies that will enable emerging economies to develop sustainably. This is only way that we can both save our planet and retain our position of leadership in the world.
Check out the pictures from this article in National Geographic. They sort of capture the feeling of the place, but make it look a little nicer than it is. Maybe it is the fact that the camera makes the spaces look larger than they are, and that you can’t smell a picture. Still, looking at these reminds me of the place and catches in my throat a bit. This is one of the nicer slums. I don’t want to ever forget this. I want our children to be aware of the global poor.
Monday, December 8, 2008
Snapshots of Life 3
Sunday, December 7, 2008
Snapshots of Life 2 - Creighton the Cowboy
Saturday, December 6, 2008
Snapshots of Life 1
At 3 months along I was already starting to show and changed into maternity clothes.
Some mornings are double-fisting, feet on the table kind of mornings, especially when Mom is too tired and ill to do more about it than laugh and take a picture.
And some days I just join him and am happier for it.


