Ben often sends New York Times articles my way when he thinks they may be of some interest to me.Today he sent me one that reminded me of my dad, and the values he taught.
The Case for Working With Your Hands by Matthew B. Crawford was well written and struck a chord with my hard work ethic. As a teenager I actually didn't mind de-tasseling corn, delighting at being outside during

the early hours of the day. It also allowed me a chance to really think, pray and exercise my ascetic self. Sometimes I wonder if there is a business that could touch on the feeling I had as I put in a full day's work. Crawford, who is having his book, “Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry Into the Value of Work", published this week, ponders this about a motorcycle specialist,
"Fred’s life as an independent tradesman gave me an image that I kept coming back to: someone who really knows what he is doing, losing himself in work that is genuinely useful and has a certain integrity to it. He also seemed to be having a lot of fun."
I'm not comparing de-tasseling corn with Fred's business, but I have always been on the lookout for a kinesetic job that has integrity and qualities that give a sense of satisfaction at the end of the day. My floral business arranging original designs for brides came as close to fulfilling this as anything. Perhaps it was the personal aspect of direct interaction with clients combined with a tactile skill. I identify with Crawford's sense of place because customers became more like friends throughout the process.
"As is the case with many independent mechanics, my business is based entirely on word of mouth. I sometimes barter services with machinists and metal fabricators. This has a very different feel than transactions with money; it situates me in a community. The result is that I really don’t want to mess up anybody’s motorcycle or charge more than a fair price. You often hear people complain about mechanics and other tradespeople whom they take to be dishonest or incompetent. I am sure this is sometimes justified. But it is also true that the mechanic deals with a large element of chance.
I once accidentally dropped a feeler gauge down into the crankcase of a Kawasaki Ninja that was practically brand new, while performing its first scheduled valve adjustment. I escaped a complete tear-down of the motor only through an operation that involved the use of a stethoscope, another pair of trusted hands and the sort of concentration we associate with a bomb squad. When finally I laid my fingers on that feeler gauge, I felt as if I had cheated death. I don’t remember ever feeling so alive as in the hours that followed.
Often as not, however, such crises do not end in redemption. Moments of elation are counterbalanced with failures, and these, too, are vivid, taking place right before your eyes. With stakes that are often high and immediate, the manual trades elicit heedful absorption in work. They are punctuated by moments of pleasure that take place against a darker backdrop: a keen awareness of catastrophe as an always-present possibility. The core experience is one of individual responsibility, supported by face-to-face interactions between tradesman and customer."
It is so true that the feeling of responsibility can be overwhelming when the potential for catastrophe is just around the corner. There is definitely a buzz of excitement when the flowers are picked up for an event, because working with nature, no matter how engineered the cut-flower industry is, you never know what surprises are in store. I was the responsible one playing the role of designer, consultant, salesman and manager, experiencing the social aspects of each position. The one that challenged me the most was that of consultant, because it forced me to act more like a middle manager in the sense that I was maintaining an image of my business to the bride. Crawford compares this role with the independent tradesman:
Contrast the experience of being a middle manager. This is a stock figure of ridicule, but the sociologist Robert Jackall spent years inhabiting the world of corporate managers, conducting interviews, and he poignantly describes the “moral maze” they feel trapped in. Like the mechanic, the manager faces the possibility of disaster at any time. But in his case these disasters feel arbitrary; they are typically a result of corporate restructurings, not of physics. A manager has to make many decisions for which he is accountable. Unlike an entrepreneur with his own business, however, his decisions can be reversed at any time by someone higher up the food chain (and there is always someone higher up the food chain). It’s important for your career that these reversals not look like defeats, and more generally you have to spend a lot of time managing what others think of you. Survival depends on a crucial insight: you can’t back down from an argument that you initially made in straightforward language, with moral conviction, without seeming to lose your integrity. So managers learn the art of provisional thinking and feeling, expressed in corporate doublespeak, and cultivate a lack of commitment to their own actions. Nothing is set in concrete the way it is when you are, for example, pouring concrete.
Luckily I was also the one "higher up the food chain"! I've worked at companies where I did not have the luxury of being able to change my mind about decisions, and was forced to consider personal integrity with company image. I keep wondering if there is any business out there that would be suited to my preferences and convictions other than my own start-up. At times I also think there's no profit in any trade that I could confidently pursue, but Crawford thinks differently.
Ultimately it is enlightened self-interest, then, not a harangue about humility or public-spiritedness, that will compel us to take a fresh look at the trades. The good life comes in a variety of forms. This variety has become difficult to see; our field of aspiration has narrowed into certain channels. But the current perplexity in the economy seems to be softening our gaze. Our peripheral vision is perhaps recovering, allowing us to consider the full range of lives worth choosing. For anyone who feels ill suited by disposition to spend his days sitting in an office, the question of what a good job looks like is now wide open.
Thank goodness!
Now to ponder whether or not the stay-at-home mom has found that peculiar variety of the good life. And by whose definition?