ser·en·dip·i·ty –noun
| 1. | an aptitude for making desirable discoveries by accident. |
| 2. | good fortune; luck: the serendipity of getting the first job she applied for. |
prov·i·dence –noun
| 1. | (often initial capital letter ) the foreseeing care and guidance of God or nature over the creatures of the earth. |
| 2. | (initial capital letter ) God, esp. when conceived as omnisciently directing the universe and the affairs of humankind with wise benevolence. |
| 3. | a manifestation of divine care or direction. |
| 4. | provident or prudent management of resources; prudence. |
| 5. | foresight; provident care. |
)
2 comments:
It seems to me that the difference is in the source of the good fortune; with providence, God is the source and he acts with intent, with serendipity, chance is the source. That's something like saying there is no actual source. Either way, with serendipity, there's no intent.
I take it that what you're getting at is that there's no such thing as luck. I didn't just happen to stumble upon that great hole-in-the-wall restaurant, the platypus didn't just evolve that way, and I somewhat miraculously rolled a 12 in Monopoly and landed on Go instead of Boardwalk.
Maybe that last one's a little absurd. But I would argue for serendipity on some level above Monopoly. I'd call anything fortunate that happens Serendipitous if I thought it was too small for God to give a rat's patoot about. Finding a parking place near the Royal Mile in Des Moines: serendipitous. Finding one near Giordano's in Chicago (the most divine pizza on the planet): now we might be talking providential. Then again, I want to say there's more to it than just assigning a name based on what I think God cares about.
Thomas Aquinas makes the case that a world that can be governed by itself is a better world than one in which God makes everything happen miraculously. A fire that can burn apart from God being in the fire demonstrates the intelligence of God better than God having to show up to do the burning himself. I like to extrapolate that idea wherever possible, and I think it applies to good fortune, too. Sometimes God acts in providence, but much of the time he's set things up to work independently. In such a world, I think we might find examples of serendipity.
Then again, you might make the case that such a wonderful, autonomous world is providential in the broader sense of the word, and I might have to agree with you there.
Conclusion: Great question!
Thanks for your thoughts! I always appreciate them! Cheers, Sasha
Post a Comment