Monday, March 24, 2008

The War Prayer

I finally finished a book a few weeks ago. Actually, it was more like a poem, but I am counting it nonetheless! (Now to finish the other 4 I'm currently reading.)

I read The War Prayer by Mark Twain. It is one of those pieces that makes you reconsider your said, or unsaid, position on pacifism.

I grew up in a Mennonite community where pacifism was one of our distinguishing traits. Everyone who asked, "Mennonite? Is that like the Amish or something?" would remember at least this one particular if nothing else. So while Mennonites have several unique traditions and doctrines, further explanations will have to be for another post.

After reading The War Prayer I was reminded of the belief that my forefathers fervently sought to live out. And how, like the last line of the prose said, "It was believed afterward that the man was a lunatic, because there was no sense in what he said."

That was their point! They were willing to be lunatics for the sake of the gospel of Jesus and many were martyred for trying to be peaceful. I have always struggled with what this means for me personally, and for the country I live in. I do not know that I am any closer to a defined position on pacifism than when I first read the book, especially as it relates to foreign policy. However, in wrestling with the concept of personal pacifism, I am more aware of the fact that the choices I make may not always have the outcome I truly wish for.

I believe in pacifism as a radical way to show love to those who do not know Jesus and for the sake of peace-keeping as far as it depends on me. However, I don't think I could passively let another person harm me. Does this mean I wish harm to others? No. Does this mean I watch others being harmed and do nothing? I have been guilty of this. Does this mean putting boundaries on others for protection of self and/or others can have negative effects? Possibly.

There is so much to wrestle with in the debate and I wonder where the better way, the higher road of Jesus actually lies? Passages such as Matthew 5:38-42 speak of purposeful pacifism with the radical call to "... not resist an evil person". What about when doing nothing to stop injustice becomes an act of enabling evil? Is God asking us to forsake ourselves, and then also to forsake those we could help?

Biblegateway.com has a commentary that is definitely worth reading regarding this difficult passage. Their understanding is that,
"Jesus' words strike at the very core of human selfishness, summoning us to value others above ourselves in concrete and consistent ways. Some misread this text as if it says not to oppose injustice; what it really says, however, is that we should be so unselfish and trust God so much that we leave our vindication with him. We have no honor or property worth defending compared with the opportunity to show how much we love God and everyone else."
(See cross reference Rom. 12:17-21.) Thinking back to Good Friday and Resurrection Day, Jesus lived this out to the greatest extent (see I Peter 2:19-24).

As we seek to live according to God's "law of love", it does not mean we are passive at injustice. The commentary explains further:
While Jesus' teaching cannot be conformed to the agendas of those who advocate violent revolution, no matter how just their cause, neither does it mean total passivity in the face of evil. It does not mean that an abused wife must remain in the home in the face of abuse; it does not mean that God expects people being massacred to remain instead of fleeing (compare Mt 2:13-20; 10:23).

But whether persecuted as Christians or for other reasons, we must respond with love and kindness (like the workers at a pregnancy-support clinic who brought food out to abortion-rights picketers). We must resist injustice and refuse to comply with demands that compromise justice; but we must do so in kindness and love, not with violence or retribution.
What does it mean to not value our honor or property above loving God and others? Dependence on God, continuous repentance, focus on God's kingdom, and letting go of rights and vindication with a willingness to give is my best guess. What's yours?

3 comments:

Steven Douglas said...

You wrestle with weighty things, Sasha, and are a wondeful and poignant writer. Keep it up. I am going to put your blog on my blog roll.

I struggled with ideas on pacifism for some time. I have landed on a precarious position. I will not resist someone who wants just my possessions (and I know that's all they want). I will not resist the mugger, and will, in fact, give my belongings to them cheerfully, especially if there is any chance at all to share the gospel. But if there is an attacker or robber in our home in the middle of the night and is aggressive, or I feel my wife (or hypethetical children) are endangered, I will not hesitate to use force, and deadly force at that. I, as a man, feel that it is my God-mandated duty to protect and care for my family.

Blessings,
Steve

Anonymous said...

The end of Corey's sermon on Sunday was timely. Put in the place on the muggy, I am not sure I would able to respond the way that he did.

Sasha said...

Here is the link to the sermon story that Corey read this past Sunday.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=89164759